Thursday, 16 October 2014

Lebanon's Arabic press digest – Oct. 17, 2014



The following are a selection of stories from Lebanese newspapers that may be of interest to Daily Star readers. The Daily Star cannot vouch for the accuracy of these reports.


Al-Joumhouria


Jumblatt resumes visits to Lebanese leaders


PSP leader Walid Jumblatt’s shuttle between Lebanese leaders picks up pace Friday with a visit to Lebanese Forces chief Samir Geagea in Maarab.


He will be accompanied by former minister Ghazi Aridi and MPs Nehme Tohme and Henry Helou.


Separately, progress has been made after negotiations with Nusra Front over the release of the 27 Lebanese soldiers and policemen held by Islamist militants resumed 10 days ago.


Results are expected to emerge with the imminent return of the Qatari mediator.


Al-Liwaa


No clear demands from ISIS, Nusra


Neither ISIS nor Nusra Front has set out clear demands and the assurances obtained by the Lebanese government through mediators are kind of guarantees.


Meanwhile, information made available to Al-Liwaa said military and security agencies were seriously dealing with warnings that had received about a possible military escalation on the border with Syria.


More to follow ...



Advertisement



Military bust come under fire in north Lebanon, soldier killed



BEIRUT: A Lebanese Army soldier was killed early Friday when a military bus carrying troops along the road in Bireh in the northern Akkar province came under gunfire.


The state-run National News Agency identified the fatality from the dawn attack as Jean Jammal al-Hashem.


It gave no other details.



Advertisement



Salam denies hostage talks have taken negative turn


BEIRUT: Although Prime Minister Tammam Salam assured the Cabinet Thursday that mediation efforts to free the 27 Lebanese hostages were making progress, a source close to the militants said the negotiations had taken “a very negative turn” in the past few days.


The hostage crisis dominated discussions during the Cabinet’s weekly session, and Salam told ministers negotiations to secure the release of the servicemen held hostage by ISIS and Nusra Front militants were continuing to make progress, political sources told The Daily Star.


Salam dismissed media reports that the negotiations had taken a turn for the worse.


He told ministers that Secretary-General of the Higher Relief Committee Maj. Gen. Mohammad Kheir was updating the families of the hostages on a daily basis.


However, a source close to the militants said negotiations to free the hostages had taken “a very negative turn” in the last six days, blaming the lack of a unified Cabinet stance.


ISIS has placed the hostage crisis under the Nusra Front’s control so the two groups would have a unified set of demands, which, if met, would secure the release of all the hostages, the source told The Daily Star. The nine hostages currently held by ISIS would be transferred to the Nusra Front when their requests are met.


“ISIS is backing the Nusra Front in negotiations. There is a de facto agreement between the two.”


The Qatari delegation overseeing the talks has been negotiating with militants through a Syrian mediator who is working on its behalf. A meeting between the Syrian mediator and the militants takes place at least once a week on Arsal’s outskirts, with the next meeting scheduled in the coming two days, the source said.


The mediator has established a good working relationship with the Nusra Front which, according to the source, has delivered a clear set of demands that includes the release of Islamist inmates in Roumieh Prison.


Despite that relationship, the Syrian mediator is receiving mixed messages from Beirut, which is hindering his ability to communicate a clear stand. “The absence of a unified official stance is causing confusion for the Syrian businessman, who is lost over what message to relay to the militants,” the source said.


The families of the hostages released two statements Thursday, the first threatening that “tomorrow will be a black Friday in Beirut if no positive developments occur in the issue of our sons.” Later, in a statement released after meeting Kheir, the families said they would hold off escalating their protests after recognizing the government’s efforts to secure the release of their loved ones.


During the Cabinet session, a spat erupted over spending between Public Works and Transportation Minister Ghazi Zeaiter and Foreign Minister Gebran Bassil, prompting Salam to intervene, political sources said. The row was related to the amount of money to be invested in regions where MP Michel Aoun’s Free Patriotic Movement enjoys wide support.


The session, which lasted more than five hours, failed to reach a decision over several items on the agenda, including renewing the tender for Sukleen and Lebanon’s two major mobile operators touch and Alfa.



International community stands with Lebanon: U.N. envoy


BEIRUT: The international community is greatly concerned about the stability of Lebanon, but stands firmly behind the country as it faces threats from Islamist militants, the United Nations special envoy to Syria said Thursday.


The remarks by Staffan de Mistura, made after meeting Prime Minister Tammam Salam, underscored the international community’s growing worries over the threats posed to Lebanon’s stability by ISIS and Nusra Front militants who battled the Lebanese Army in August and are now holed up on the Bekaa town’s outskirts.


De Mistura, currently on a regional tour aimed at promoting a political solution to end the war in Syria, now in its fourth year, also held talks with Foreign Minister Gebran Bassil. He also met with Hezbollah’s deputy leader Sheikh Naim Qassem, whose party has sent fighters to Syria to help President Bashar Assad’s forces in the war against rebels.


“The international community is very concerned about the stability of Lebanon, which has been paying a heavy price due to the proximity of the ongoing conflict in Syria,” de Mistura told reporters after holding talks with Salam at the Grand Serail.


“The international community stands firmly with Lebanon. We are fully aware of the price and the burden that Lebanon and the Lebanese people are paying and have paid during this period. We also see with concern what has been happening just recently, just on the border,” he said.


The Lebanese Army battled ISIS and Nusra Front militants for five days in Arsal in early August after the militants briefly overran the town. The Army has since then engaged in intermittent clashes with militants near the border. The militants are still holding captive 27 soldiers and policemen they captured during the fierce fighting.


Declaring that Lebanon’s stability is important for the world, De Mistura said: “At the same time, we are confident that, with the international community, Lebanon once again will be able to overcome this period. The stability of Lebanon is important for the region and for the international community. And of course that also means that the Lebanese political environment should be stabilizing the sooner and the better because the stronger Lebanon is, the easier it will be to face what I think is going to be a very crucial period but hopefully with some type or form of political process in Syria.”


The U.N. envoy said he discussed with Salam the security of the region rattled by the recent military advances of ISIS in Iraq and Syria.


He said this is his second tour of the region since he was appointed the U.N. envoy to Syria. He added that he plans to visit Iran, Turkey and other regional countries, in addition to New York and Moscow.


“We are still in the process of understanding what has changed in the region in terms of some perception of how to address in a political format, through a political process, the conflict in Syria due to new factors which have taken place in the region and in particular [the expansion of] Daesh,” de Mistura said, using the Arabic acronym for ISIS.


However, diplomatic sources said de Mistura’s attempts to relaunch the political process in Syria would not be easy given the fact that the international community was preoccupied with the war against ISIS.


“The international community’s delay in finding a political solution to the Syrian crisis will prolong the crisis and increase threats in Syria and Lebanon,” the sources said.


During the meeting also attended by U.N. Special Coordinator for Lebanon Derek Plumbly, de Mistura and Salam also discussed the Syrian refugee crisis and other regional issues. He said the international community must help Lebanon cope with the presence of more than 1 million Syria refugees in its territory.


“It is an issue [Syrian refugees] that Lebanon needs to be helped on. There is a limit we know to what one country alone can do and that is why the international community must and has to help Lebanon to face this difficult crisis,” he said.


Speaking to reporters after meeting Qassem at the latter’s office in Beirut’s southern suburbs, de Mistura said his visit to Hezbollah was part of consultations with all the parties that could help find a political solution in the region, particularly in Syria.


Viewpoints were identical [with Hezbollah] that a solution in Syria should be a political one, de Mistura said.


For his part, Qassem wished the U.N. envoy success in his mission, while stressing that the only way to end the war in Syria is through a political solution.


“It has been confirmed that a political solution will save Syria and its people. Everyone must expect painful concessions in this respect. But it is the only solution at hand. There is no other solution,” Qassem said, according to a statement released by Hezbollah’s office.


Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Gennady Gatilov has said de Mistura would visit Moscow Oct. 21. “We consider his arrival to be important because by that time he will have visited all the main capitals of the region and met with many political figures,” Gatilov told the Interfax news agency. “We expect him to bring fresh ideas as a result of his contacts in the region.”



Mass Army defections unlikely scenario


The Army Command does not fear large-scale defections into the ranks of jihadists, according to a high-profile Army source.


“Sunni servicemen will not defect from the Army, because they have clear knowledge of how the military is behaving and they know that allegations by terrorist groups that the Army is oppressing Sunnis are mere lies,” the source told The Daily Star Thursday.


“The head of the Army battalion deployed in Arsal is a Sunni – why hasn’t he defected?” the source said. “Some of the soldiers killed or kidnapped during the Arsal battles are also Sunnis.”


The source explained that the military establishment, whose members are from Lebanon’s various sects, was treating all religious groups in the country equally.


“Just as we arrest Sunni suspects, we also chase and detain Shiite fugitives.”


He pointed to repetitive Army raids on the Baalbek neighborhood of Hay al-Sharawneh, where many Shiite suspects often seek refuge.


He also said the Army had arrested members of the powerful Shiite Meqdad clan in 2012 after they kidnapped Syrian refugees and Turkish nationals in Lebanon.


The source explained that only soldiers Atef Mohammad Saadeddine, who announced that he had entered the ranks of the Nusra Front in July, and Abdallah Shehadeh, who joined the same group this month, have actually fled Army ranks.


The others were sacked from the Army over misconduct way before they announced their joining of terrorist groups, the source said, in reference to two other soldiers who announced that they had joined ISIS and the Nusra Front earlier this month.


The source downplayed accusations by the Nusra Front, ISIS and other Islamist groups that the Army was under Hezbollah’s control.


“We receive military aid from the U.S. which Hezbollah describes as the ‘great Satan.’”


The military official dismissed claims that the Army was cracking down on Lebanese who were aiding Syrian rebels, while refraining from taking action against Hezbollah militants crossing the border to fight alongside the Syrian regime.


“We are not arresting residents of Tripoli who are fighting in Syria and returning home, although we know their names,” the source said.


“Even extremist groups positioned in the outskirts of Arsal now, if they drop their arms and abandon their takfiri ideology, we won’t mind that they live in Lebanon like other Syrian refugees,” he said.


The source described Arsal as the “hot spot” in Lebanon at the present time.


He said that the course of battles in the outskirts of the northeastern town and adjacent Syrian territories indicated that ISIS and the Nusra Front were now focusing on taking over a village on the Syrian side of the border.


“But who knows? If snow falls early this year, they might choose the short route and attack Arsal again. We are waiting for them,” the source said.


He said it was unlikely that radical Syrian rebels would attack the southern region of Arqoub, which includes the areas of Kfar Shuba, Shebaa and Hasbaya, similar to how they did in Arsal.


“The demographic structure in Hasbaya is different. The plan of the terrorist groups is to have a sea outlet and it is very hard to reach the sea from Arqoub,” the source said. “UNIFIL troops are also present in the area.”


The source described the situation in Tripoli as “excellent,” particularly after fugitives Shadi al-Mawlawi an Osama Mansour evacuated a mosque in the neighborhood of Bab al-Tabbaneh.


The source stressed that the crackdown on terrorist cells across the country was ongoing, although sometimes it was away from the media spotlight.


He said that despite their deep differences, the various political groups in Lebanon were interested in preventing the overall situation from exploding.


“It is clear from the way the government was formed and how it is functioning. Ministers set aside all their disputes and attend the Cabinet session every week,” he said.


“There is an international umbrella protecting Lebanon,” he added. “But this does not mean that we should stand by idly. All political groups should also do their part in protecting stability.”



Hezbollah blames Future for assaults on Army in Tripoli


BEIRUT: Hezbollah dismissed Thursday accusations that it was involved in assaults against the Lebanese Army in Tripoli, pointing the finger back at the Future Movement, which Hezbollah said ultimately bore responsibility for the attacks.


Officials from the Future Movement and March 14 media outlets “have issued false accusations over repeated assaults against the Lebanese Army in Tripoli, pinning the blame on individuals, it alleges, are allied ... with Hezbollah,” a statement released by Hezbollah’s media office said.


The statement came after prominent March 14 figures, including Justice Minister Ashraf Rifi, said Hezbollah was implicated in the attacks on Army positions in the northern port city.


Rifi Monday claimed that “investigations had revealed the identities of those who threw the grenades on the Army bases and checkpoints,” who turned out to be “from Hezbollah’s circle and aim to create a conflict between the Army and the city’s residents.”


The Muslim Scholars Committee Wednesday echoed the claims, saying “investigations revealed that Hezbollah is responsible for attacks on the Lebanese Army.”


Hezbollah considered the accusations to be “baseless” and “void of any truth,” negating the claims by saying that “those responsible for firing at the Army in Tripoli are known by the residents of the town, the Lebanese Army and security forces.” None of the perpetrators are “friends or allies” of Hezbollah, the party said.


Hezbollah claimed that the perpetrators were “close allies of the Future Movement,” which has supplied the necessary “legal cover to prevent their trials.”


Hezbollah further decried the accusations by stressing that the party “rejects any assault on the Lebanese Army.” Any attack on the military is “a grave national crime,” the severity of which is only worsened by the fact that the Army is waging battles against terrorists, Hezbollah said.


The statement went on to call for the perpetrators to be brought to justice. The party also hoped that investigations would reveal their “identities, goals and the groups they are working for.”


In the latest incident in a spate of Army-related violence in the city, a resident of the Beddawi refugee camp was killed during a shoot-out with soldiers Thursday evening. The gunfight broke out after the Army tried to arrest someone suspected of killing a soldier, the National News Agency said.


Earlier this week, the Lebanese Army beefed up security measures in Tripoli following repeated attacks against the military.



Mass Army defections unlikely scenario


The Army Command does not fear large-scale defections into the ranks of jihadists, according to a high-profile Army source.


“Sunni servicemen will not defect from the Army, because they have clear knowledge of how the military is behaving and they know that allegations by terrorist groups that the Army is oppressing Sunnis are mere lies,” the source told The Daily Star Thursday.


“The head of the Army battalion deployed in Arsal is a Sunni – why hasn’t he defected?” the source said. “Some of the soldiers killed or kidnapped during the Arsal battles are also Sunnis.”


The source explained that the military establishment, whose members are from Lebanon’s various sects, was treating all religious groups in the country equally.


“Just as we arrest Sunni suspects, we also chase and detain Shiite fugitives.”


He pointed to repetitive Army raids on the Baalbek neighborhood of Hay al-Sharawneh, where many Shiite suspects often seek refuge.


He also said the Army had arrested members of the powerful Shiite Meqdad clan in 2012 after they kidnapped Syrian refugees and Turkish nationals in Lebanon.


The source explained that only soldiers Atef Mohammad Saadeddine, who announced that he had entered the ranks of the Nusra Front in July, and Abdallah Shehadeh, who joined the same group this month, have actually fled Army ranks.


The others were sacked from the Army over misconduct way before they announced their joining of terrorist groups, the source said, in reference to two other soldiers who announced that they had joined ISIS and the Nusra Front earlier this month.


The source downplayed accusations by the Nusra Front, ISIS and other Islamist groups that the Army was under Hezbollah’s control.


“We receive military aid from the U.S. which Hezbollah describes as the ‘great Satan.’”


The military official dismissed claims that the Army was cracking down on Lebanese who were aiding Syrian rebels, while refraining from taking action against Hezbollah militants crossing the border to fight alongside the Syrian regime.


“We are not arresting residents of Tripoli who are fighting in Syria and returning home, although we know their names,” the source said.


“Even extremist groups positioned in the outskirts of Arsal now, if they drop their arms and abandon their takfiri ideology, we won’t mind that they live in Lebanon like other Syrian refugees,” he said.


The source described Arsal as the “hot spot” in Lebanon at the present time.


He said that the course of battles in the outskirts of the northeastern town and adjacent Syrian territories indicated that ISIS and the Nusra Front were now focusing on taking over a village on the Syrian side of the border.


“But who knows? If snow falls early this year, they might choose the short route and attack Arsal again. We are waiting for them,” the source said.


He said it was unlikely that radical Syrian rebels would attack the southern region of Arqoub, which includes the areas of Kfar Shuba, Shebaa and Hasbaya, similar to how they did in Arsal.


“The demographic structure in Hasbaya is different. The plan of the terrorist groups is to have a sea outlet and it is very hard to reach the sea from Arqoub,” the source said. “UNIFIL troops are also present in the area.”


The source described the situation in Tripoli as “excellent,” particularly after fugitives Shadi al-Mawlawi an Osama Mansour evacuated a mosque in the neighborhood of Bab al-Tabbaneh.


The source stressed that the crackdown on terrorist cells across the country was ongoing, although sometimes it was away from the media spotlight.


He said that despite their deep differences, the various political groups in Lebanon were interested in preventing the overall situation from exploding.


“It is clear from the way the government was formed and how it is functioning. Ministers set aside all their disputes and attend the Cabinet session every week,” he said.


“There is an international umbrella protecting Lebanon,” he added. “But this does not mean that we should stand by idly. All political groups should also do their part in protecting stability.”



Just 1 percent of Lebanese Sunnis positive about ISIS


BEIRUT: Just 1 percent of Lebanon’s Sunni population has a positive opinion of ISIS, according to new poll commissioned by the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. Still, that means there are probably “a few thousand” ISIS sympathizers in Lebanon, according to David Pollock, the director of the Washington Institute’s Fikra Forum, who designed the survey.


No Lebanese Sunnis in the poll reported “very positive” attitudes toward ISIS, but approximately 1 percent of Sunnis said they harbor “fairly positive” views of the Islamist terror group.


Of the 1,000 Lebanese interviewed for the survey, not a single Christian, Druze or Shiite respondent was supportive of ISIS.


Pollock says that while ISIS itself poses little military threat to Lebanon, the country’s stability could be threatened by the ongoing Syrian conflict which continues to fan sectarian flames.


“I think that the main threat is probably not ... the direct one of people coming into Lebanon trying to promote ISIS or actually engaging in terrorist activities inside Lebanon,” Pollock told The Daily Star. “I think the main threat is probably an indirect one, that the existence of this conflict just across the border will further inflame Lebanon’s own sectarian tensions, which don’t necessarily have to do with ISIS,” he explained. “ISIS itself is not a polarizing factor,” he added.


While the poll was conducted using a random, representative sample of the Lebanese population, no Syrian refugees were included. Pollock cited budgetary, security and administrative restrictions as the reason why refugees, who now comprise more than 20 percent of Lebanon’s population, were not invited to participate in the survey.


The results might have been different had refugees been included, Pollock admitted. “I don’t know, but it’s possible that among all the million-plus Syrian refugees in Lebanon there are more [who support ISIS],” he said. Pollock hopes to conduct a similar follow-up survey among Syrian refugees in Lebanon.


Moreover Pollock says that if he were to redo the poll, he would ask participants their views about the Al-Qaeda affiliated Nusra Front. While ISIS has drawn sharp criticism for its brutality and extreme interpretation of Shariah law, it is possible that a not insignificant number of Lebanese would sympathize with the Nusra Front, which many see as a more moderate Sunni opposition group.


While the fact that ISIS enjoys negligible support among the Lebanese population did not surprise Pollock, he was taken aback by the level of confessional polarization in the country. “It’s more extreme than I might have predicted, the polarization of different groups,” Pollock admitted.


For example, Shiites reported 96 percent and 97 percent approval ratings for the Iranian and Syrian regimes respectively. But just 12 percent of Sunnis hold favorable views of the Iranian government, and only 14 percent approve of the Syrian regime.


Perhaps unexpectedly, a landslide 92 percent of Shiites support Hezbollah but just 8 percent of Sunnis back the resistance group. According to the study, 39 percent of Christians approve of Hezbollah.


Views about the U.S. also vary widely between the sects in Lebanon. While 39 percent of Christians have positive views of America, that drops to 30 percent for Sunnis and Druze. But just 3 percent of Shiites hold favorable views of the United States.


Pollock also conducted the survey in Saudi Arabia and Egypt, both predominantly Sunni countries. In Saudi Arabia, 5 percent of the population, approximately half a million people, support ISIS. About 1.5 million Egyptians, 3 percent of the population, champion the radical Islamist group.



Polio vaccination campaign stays the course


ZAHLE, Lebanon: The girl arrived with her brother in tow. Ali, a 5-year-old Syrian refugee, had not been vaccinated against polio yet. He had missed class at the informal school that morning because he was helping chop wood for the family ahead of winter.


Ali was taken to the vaccination staff with Beyond Association, a local NGO responsible for the polio immunization drive in the camps which administered the oral vaccine and logged him in their running lists.


“Can I have my balloon?” he asked, and was on his way.


The boy was one of dozens of children in the makeshift settlement to receive the vaccine, part of a nationwide campaign meant to protect Lebanon against a resurgence of polio that began in war-torn Syria.


During Tuesday’s launch, Health Minister Wael Abu Faour warned that Lebanon had become “extremely susceptible” to a polio outbreak.


The Daily Star accompanied World Health Organization staff as they toured refugee settlements in the Bekaa Valley and vaccine storage facilities in an inspection meant to assess the ongoing campaign to vaccinate refugee and Lebanese children against polio.


Lebanon, along with other countries in Syria’s vicinity, began polio vaccination drives after an outbreak was detected in Syria. In October last year, the Syrian regime announced that 13 cases of type 1 polio had been detected in Deir al-Zor. A total of 24 cases had been reported by May 2014, the latest in Iraq.


The last case of polio in Lebanon was reported in 1994 and the country was declared polio-free in 2002 by the WHO.


For the vaccination campaign, UNICEF has procured some 1.5 million doses to be used in Lebanon.


The vaccine is the only tool available to protect the children, and so it is all the more important that it is widely received, given polio’s ease of transmission and the lack of treatment for the paralysis that could result from contracting the virus.


Polio can lurk hidden – for every child who develops paralysis from the disease, about 200 others may be infected but do not develop serious symptoms, though they could still transfer it to others.


Another problem is that, while most Lebanese have received the routine polio vaccine injection in visits to private physicians, they need to take the oral vaccine too.


And while they are individually immune to the virus, they could transmit it to vulnerable family members, like newborns, who have not been vaccinated.


Magdi Sharaf, the WHO’s point man on polio in Lebanon, roamed the camp asking women and children whether vaccination staff had visited them, examining the database, including the identification numbers of the children and their vaccination cards.


Sharaf said the aim of the vaccination drive was to raise the immunity levels of the Syrian and Lebanese communities here.


Since the Syrian community is dispersed, Beyond Association was assigned the task of vaccinating informal settlements where Syrians live, in a “house-to-house or tent-to-tent campaign.”


For the Lebanese, the WHO is overseeing vaccinations in schools, kindergartens, health care centers and hospitals, as well as providing vaccines to private physicians.


They have also toured the Lebanese government’s storage facilities which are, they said, among the more advanced systems globally, since they use solar power to ensure a steady electricity supply to keep the vaccines cool.


Lebanon held national immunization campaigns in November and December of last year in collaboration with the WHO, as well as in March and April 2014. These were followed with “mop-up” campaigns to vaccinate any children who had slipped through the cracks in high-risk communities.


The fifth national drive is currently ongoing until Oct. 21, and a sixth will occur in November.


The current campaign aims to vaccinate 550,000 children. It is impossible to vaccinate 100 percent of children, since there are roughly 10,000 Syrians arriving in Lebanon and 6,000 leaving the country on a daily basis.


There are over 1.1 million registered Syrian refugees in Lebanon, half of whom are under 17.


Still, the campaigns, which are synchronized with neighboring countries like Iraq, Jordan and Turkey, must continue until the polio threat in Syria is eradicated.


Sharaf said it was easier to immunize refugees than it was to immunize the Lebanese, because most don’t realize that their children need to take the oral vaccine in addition to the routine vaccine given to them by private doctors.


“Reaching refugees is easy, because these people are demanding it,” he said.


“They come from an infected area and have seen the paralyzed children, and they are suffering.


“Our challenge is the Lebanese themselves. They haven’t seen polio cases since 2002, so they have completely forgotten that disease.”


Sharaf said most parents were asking their private doctors if they should take the vaccines, and their doctors, who were not informed about the campaigns initially by the WHO, were saying no. So while 90 percent of Syrian children were vaccinated in the last immunization drives, just 70 percent of Lebanese children had been immunized.


The organization has since reached out to private doctors, who are now advising Lebanese patients to give their children the oral treatment.


The way the routine injection works is similar to the way most other vaccines work – it injects a weakened dose of the virus, which allows the body to produce antigens that can protect the body if it is infected.


But multiple doses of the vaccine are needed over time to keep the virus out.


Sharaf said the risk in Lebanon is “high,” because of the ongoing displacement of refugees from Syria.


“This is a continuous risk; we are not able to relax,” he said.


The risk is also rising with Iraqis fleeing to Lebanon amid the advance of ISIS there.


Though Iraq has a much smaller number of Syrian refugees than Lebanon, there have been cases of polio reported there.


That there have been none in Lebanon is largely due to the fact that all Syrian children entering Lebanon on the border are vaccinated against polio.


The four vaccination posts on the border, together with another set up at Beirut’s airport, vaccinate about 10,000 children per month.


But other challenges facing doctors in Lebanon include misinformation and negative attitudes to the vaccine caused by recent tragic cases of vaccine-related deaths in Syria.


At least 15 children died in Idlib this summer when they were given a measles vaccine that included Atracurium, a muscle relaxant that was not supposed to be mixed with the vaccine.


In addition, earlier this month, a Lebanese girl was said to have died after receiving a contaminated vaccination, although the family maid was later blamed for the death.


Another challenge is posed by Arsal, the troubled northeastern town that was briefly overrun by ISIS and Nusra Front militants in August. In addition to the recent unrest in the town, problems are caused by the fact that refugees arrive illegally through the mountain region on Arsal’s outskirts to Qaa near the border.


Maria Assi, the CEO of Beyond, said the NGO maintained a presence in the area nevertheless and had pledged to vaccinate all the children in Arsal’s refugee camps, as well as children in Qaa, despite the security concerns. And she said physicians had repeatedly allayed the fears of refugees about the vaccines.


Sharaf has messages for two key demographics that he said were crucial to the fight against polio. First, mothers are the ones who are able to stop the polio virus in the region, he said, by vaccinating their children.


Secondly, he said: “I am asking the private physicians ... to support our campaign.”



Polio vaccination campaign stays the course


ZAHLE, Lebanon: The girl arrived with her brother in tow. Ali, a 5-year-old Syrian refugee, had not been vaccinated against polio yet. He had missed class at the informal school that morning because he was helping chop wood for the family ahead of winter.


Ali was taken to the vaccination staff with Beyond Association, a local NGO responsible for the polio immunization drive in the camps which administered the oral vaccine and logged him in their running lists.


“Can I have my balloon?” he asked, and was on his way.


The boy was one of dozens of children in the makeshift settlement to receive the vaccine, part of a nationwide campaign meant to protect Lebanon against a resurgence of polio that began in war-torn Syria.


During Tuesday’s launch, Health Minister Wael Abu Faour warned that Lebanon had become “extremely susceptible” to a polio outbreak.


The Daily Star accompanied World Health Organization staff as they toured refugee settlements in the Bekaa Valley and vaccine storage facilities in an inspection meant to assess the ongoing campaign to vaccinate refugee and Lebanese children against polio.


Lebanon, along with other countries in Syria’s vicinity, began polio vaccination drives after an outbreak was detected in Syria. In October last year, the Syrian regime announced that 13 cases of type 1 polio had been detected in Deir al-Zor. A total of 24 cases had been reported by May 2014, the latest in Iraq.


The last case of polio in Lebanon was reported in 1994 and the country was declared polio-free in 2002 by the WHO.


For the vaccination campaign, UNICEF has procured some 1.5 million doses to be used in Lebanon.


The vaccine is the only tool available to protect the children, and so it is all the more important that it is widely received, given polio’s ease of transmission and the lack of treatment for the paralysis that could result from contracting the virus.


Polio can lurk hidden – for every child who develops paralysis from the disease, about 200 others may be infected but do not develop serious symptoms, though they could still transfer it to others.


Another problem is that, while most Lebanese have received the routine polio vaccine injection in visits to private physicians, they need to take the oral vaccine too.


And while they are individually immune to the virus, they could transmit it to vulnerable family members, like newborns, who have not been vaccinated.


Magdi Sharaf, the WHO’s point man on polio in Lebanon, roamed the camp asking women and children whether vaccination staff had visited them, examining the database, including the identification numbers of the children and their vaccination cards.


Sharaf said the aim of the vaccination drive was to raise the immunity levels of the Syrian and Lebanese communities here.


Since the Syrian community is dispersed, Beyond Association was assigned the task of vaccinating informal settlements where Syrians live, in a “house-to-house or tent-to-tent campaign.”


For the Lebanese, the WHO is overseeing vaccinations in schools, kindergartens, health care centers and hospitals, as well as providing vaccines to private physicians.


They have also toured the Lebanese government’s storage facilities which are, they said, among the more advanced systems globally, since they use solar power to ensure a steady electricity supply to keep the vaccines cool.


Lebanon held national immunization campaigns in November and December of last year in collaboration with the WHO, as well as in March and April 2014. These were followed with “mop-up” campaigns to vaccinate any children who had slipped through the cracks in high-risk communities.


The fifth national drive is currently ongoing until Oct. 21, and a sixth will occur in November.


The current campaign aims to vaccinate 550,000 children. It is impossible to vaccinate 100 percent of children, since there are roughly 10,000 Syrians arriving in Lebanon and 6,000 leaving the country on a daily basis.


There are over 1.1 million registered Syrian refugees in Lebanon, half of whom are under 17.


Still, the campaigns, which are synchronized with neighboring countries like Iraq, Jordan and Turkey, must continue until the polio threat in Syria is eradicated.


Sharaf said it was easier to immunize refugees than it was to immunize the Lebanese, because most don’t realize that their children need to take the oral vaccine in addition to the routine vaccine given to them by private doctors.


“Reaching refugees is easy, because these people are demanding it,” he said.


“They come from an infected area and have seen the paralyzed children, and they are suffering.


“Our challenge is the Lebanese themselves. They haven’t seen polio cases since 2002, so they have completely forgotten that disease.”


Sharaf said most parents were asking their private doctors if they should take the vaccines, and their doctors, who were not informed about the campaigns initially by the WHO, were saying no. So while 90 percent of Syrian children were vaccinated in the last immunization drives, just 70 percent of Lebanese children had been immunized.


The organization has since reached out to private doctors, who are now advising Lebanese patients to give their children the oral treatment.


The way the routine injection works is similar to the way most other vaccines work – it injects a weakened dose of the virus, which allows the body to produce antigens that can protect the body if it is infected.


But multiple doses of the vaccine are needed over time to keep the virus out.


Sharaf said the risk in Lebanon is “high,” because of the ongoing displacement of refugees from Syria.


“This is a continuous risk; we are not able to relax,” he said.


The risk is also rising with Iraqis fleeing to Lebanon amid the advance of ISIS there.


Though Iraq has a much smaller number of Syrian refugees than Lebanon, there have been cases of polio reported there.


That there have been none in Lebanon is largely due to the fact that all Syrian children entering Lebanon on the border are vaccinated against polio.


The four vaccination posts on the border, together with another set up at Beirut’s airport, vaccinate about 10,000 children per month.


But other challenges facing doctors in Lebanon include misinformation and negative attitudes to the vaccine caused by recent tragic cases of vaccine-related deaths in Syria.


At least 15 children died in Idlib this summer when they were given a measles vaccine that included Atracurium, a muscle relaxant that was not supposed to be mixed with the vaccine.


In addition, earlier this month, a Lebanese girl was said to have died after receiving a contaminated vaccination, although the family maid was later blamed for the death.


Another challenge is posed by Arsal, the troubled northeastern town that was briefly overrun by ISIS and Nusra Front militants in August. In addition to the recent unrest in the town, problems are caused by the fact that refugees arrive illegally through the mountain region on Arsal’s outskirts to Qaa near the border.


Maria Assi, the CEO of Beyond, said the NGO maintained a presence in the area nevertheless and had pledged to vaccinate all the children in Arsal’s refugee camps, as well as children in Qaa, despite the security concerns. And she said physicians had repeatedly allayed the fears of refugees about the vaccines.


Sharaf has messages for two key demographics that he said were crucial to the fight against polio. First, mothers are the ones who are able to stop the polio virus in the region, he said, by vaccinating their children.


Secondly, he said: “I am asking the private physicians ... to support our campaign.”



Rainy week douses Lebanon drought fears: weather experts


BEIRUT: Weather experts hope that this week’s heavy rainfall will make up for last year’s severe winter drought, Michel Frem, head of the Lebanese Agricultural Research Institute, said Thursday.


“The rainfall has minimized fire hazards that turn up during this time every year and it is also excellent for agriculture and the environment,” Frem told the state-run National News Agency Thursday. Experts say 700 millimetersof rainfall in the Bekaa accompanied by snowfall on the mountains would be needed to compensate for last year’s drought.


“Climate change and discrepancies with regards to the amount of rainfall across the country make it difficult for meteorologists to predict the weather,” Frem said, highlighting that the meteorology department could only forecast weather conditions a week or two in advance. Despite difficulties, Frem expects rainfall to persist throughout the months of November and December, however the prediction “is difficult to confirm.”


Heavy rainfall caused river and street flooding Tuesday night that continued well into Thursday morning across Lebanon.


According to Frem, the village of Kfar Shakhna witnessed the heaviest rainfall in the country so far with 97 millimetersof rain in the past week, a remarkable 88 millimetersincrease over the amount of rainfall for the same period last year. The village witnesses on average 62 millimetersof rain for that period.


Akkar came in second, with an estimated 94 millimetersof rainfall over the past week, a 63 millimetermarked increase compared to a meager 31 millimeters in the same period last year But heavy rainfall is not uncommon in the region which has an average of 92 millimeters


Beirut came in third with 55 millimetersof rainfall over the past week. This is an 18 millimeter increase compared to rainfall in the capital over the same period in 2013.


In the town of Riyaq in Zahle, precipitation levels went up by 32 millimeterscompared to last year while also rising 26 millimetersabove the average for the period.


The rainy trend will continue over the weekend, with rainfall and lightning expected for Saturday and Sunday, Frem said. Friday, however, will only see intermittent showers, he added.



In Hasbaya, bartering tradition endures


HASBAYA, Lebanon: In some places in the world, barter is still a way of doing business. A chicken, for example, can be traded for a rooster, or a goat for a donkey. In Lebanon, that place is the Khan market in the southern village of Hasbaya.


The market has been active for decades and has seen enormous changes. It has been renovated many times, and every Tuesday, villagers, farmers, peasants and cattle herders in south Lebanon come to offer their produce up and see what they can get in return.


“We still preserve some of the Lebanese rural traditions,” Yehya Dakr, a resident of Marjayoun, told The Daily Star as he traded his goat for a few chickens. “I buy livestock for slaughter, to organize feasts and Arabic parties. For us Arabs, we have to slaughter lambs during the special holidays.


“All of Lebanon’s sects are found in this popular market, and we are all one family. Money comes and goes, but a person’s love and their treatment of others are a treasure in these times of murder and treachery.”


Situated in Hasbaya, a town on Lebanon’s southeastern border with Israel and Syria, the market used to attract people from an enormous area, back in a time when borders were easier to cross.


“In the past, the market was a commercial station that attracted thousands of traders from Palestine and the Golan Heights,” said Fawzi Naim, a trader at the market. “The traders would transport their products and merchandise on mules and horses during times when barter was the easiest way to trade.


“Rashaya residents, for example, used to trade their pottery dishes, pitchers and cups for citrus and other plants.”


Leading several sheep he had just bought from the market “by a stroke of luck,” Hussein Makki, a butcher from the southern town of Houla explained that the market was the perfect place to make sure you got the best deal.


“I come here every Tuesday morning to pick goats and sheep, and sell them during the week,” Makki said. “Sometimes after I buy livestock, I find a better one so I trade mine with it.”


Dozens of trucks and pick-ups line up outside the market carrying more livestock for sale.


A number of UNIFIL soldiers, who work to keep peace in south Lebanon and on the U.N.-demarcated Blue Line border with Israel, often come to the market too.


“Lebanon is beautiful,” said Tago, from Colombia, who was there to buy apples and eat grilled meat. “This market is like a small town where one finds farmers living the simple life off of their plantings and livestock.”


The market is raucous, with people calling out their deals on not just animals but also grapes, pomegranates, olives and olive oil.


Negotiating to trade a sheep for some olives, Abu Mujahed pointed to the sheep he was buying. “It’s not for slaughter,” he said. “I will raise her so we can milk her and have milk and yogurt.


“Look at how beautiful this market is, I come here to buy and trade livestock,” said Haydar Moussa, from Sidon. “I buy sheep in kilos; LL8,500 for every kilo. I traveled 50 kilometers to be here with the shepherds and butchers.”


“This lamb would regret being here if he knew that I will slaughter him,” joked Saeed Akl, as he left the market for his town Labaya in the West Bekaa.


Another market frequenter, Ahmad Abu Shebli, had traded a donkey for two sheep.


“It is olive season and a donkey is capable of reaching the fields, carrying olives, and taking it to the olive mill,” he said. “So I traded him for two sheep that I can raise to have them give birth next year.”


Coming from Khulwat al-Bayada in Hasbaya, Fawzi Abu Ibrahim said: “I’ve been coming here with my father ever since I was a child, which is 60 years ago. I buy sheep for slaughter to make awarma [spiced minced meat with pine nuts], which we eat in winter days when roads are closed and the temperature drops below 7 degrees Celsius.”


Also an old-timer at the market, Hisham Kanaan from the Shebaa Farms said: “Since 1960, I’ve been trading livestock. I buy and sell and loan people who don’t have money. I examine livestock without a doctor’s stethoscope, and if I find a sick animal or one that walks funny I leave it.”


With a lamb on his back, Kanaan started calling out to potential buyers: “Come quick! Every three lambs are for LL150,000, and whoever wants to trade is welcome.”



Political TV Ad Spending Expected To Top $1 Billion



Audio for this story from All Things Considered will be available at approximately 7:00 p.m. ET.





Audie Cornish speaks with Elizabeth Wilner of Kantar Media about the landscape of political TV advertising in the run up to the 2014 election.



Navajo Presidential Race Shaken By Language Gap



Navajo presidential candidate Chris Deschene greets supporters ahead of a hearing in Window Rock, Ariz., to determine whether Deschene is fluent enough in Navajo to qualify for the presidency.i i



Navajo presidential candidate Chris Deschene greets supporters ahead of a hearing in Window Rock, Ariz., to determine whether Deschene is fluent enough in Navajo to qualify for the presidency. Felicia Fonseca/AP hide caption



itoggle caption Felicia Fonseca/AP

Navajo presidential candidate Chris Deschene greets supporters ahead of a hearing in Window Rock, Ariz., to determine whether Deschene is fluent enough in Navajo to qualify for the presidency.



Navajo presidential candidate Chris Deschene greets supporters ahead of a hearing in Window Rock, Ariz., to determine whether Deschene is fluent enough in Navajo to qualify for the presidency.


Felicia Fonseca/AP


According to Navajo law, Navajo Nation presidents must speak the Navajo language to hold office. Chris Deschene is a strong contender for the position, but there's a problem: He's not fluent in the language.


The challenge to Deschene's candidacy has become a window into how the Navajo Nation views itself and its cultural future, as well as how Native people continue to define themselves in the face of cultural change.


In August, the Navajo Nation held primaries for candidates hoping to become the next Navajo president. The two men with the most votes were Dr. Joe Shirley Jr., a two-time former president; and Deschene, a military veteran and member of the Arizona State Legislature.


However, within weeks of clearing the nation's primaries with 19 percent of the vote, Deschene was challenged by another candidate who hoped to have him disqualified for lack of language competence.


Fifty years ago, almost 90 percent of Navajo first-graders spoke Navajo fluently. Now, just over 7,000 tribal citizens are monolingual Navajo speakers, and fewer than 30 percent of first-graders can claim some level of language fluency.


Today, the Navajo Nation, much like the rest of Indian Country, faces the prospect of language loss. While the Navajo language is still spoken widely across the Southwest, it's threatened, and Deschene has come to represent that fact for people on both sides of the language divide.


"It's a really personal issue to me," says Melvatha Chee, a Navajo language instructor at the University of New Mexico. "I would like to vote for [Deschene], but I feel like I'm voting against myself if I support him. If I support a nonspeaker, I feel like I'm voting against my own work."


Others feel that they can support their language and Deschene's candidacy.


"If Deschene is told that he can't be president because he's not Navajo enough because of language, that's like telling a lot of young Navajo people that they're not good enough either because they don't speak the language," says Meredith Moss, a doctoral candidate at Arizona State University who has focused her studies on Navajo language and sociolinguistics.


At the heart of the matter for Deschene, according to Moss, is the need to use English in the context of being a representative to other nations and groups, but also being an authentic, trustworthy voice at home who can represent the positions of the Nation's elders. It is a struggle between an older generation that is genuinely Navajo and a new generation of tribal members who may see themselves more closely represented by Deschene than by his opponent.


"I think many feel that the youth are being told they're not good enough," said Moss. "They're not Navajo enough, and supporting Deschene is kind of like moving toward the new guard and saying, 'We really are Navajo; we can have that authenticity while moving forward together.' "


For many, language is the embodiment of culture, and tribal languages contain history, cosmology, traditional values and identity. Supporters of the language requirement argue that without tribal languages, Native Americans are lost, and distant from the ancestors who came before them.


But for much of history, this loss of language was not a choice. For centuries, the policy of churches, educators and government officials has been to stamp out tribal languages, through education, abuse, and any other way possible. As the saying went: Kill the Indian, save the man.


By federal government standards, there's no question that Deschene is Navajo, regardless of language. He is a citizen by blood quantum standards. He was born, raised and lives within the borders of the Navajo Nation. He is a participant in cultural events, from social dances to ceremony.


Deschene is also a graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy and a Marine Corps veteran. He has earned a law degree. Yet his lack of fluency in the Navajo language may disqualify him from becoming the next president of the largest Native nation within the United States. And people like Chee think that's fine.


"How do we approach teaching Navajo language to children so that we can actually produce speakers?" said Chee. "If I support a nonspeaker then I'm saying, 'You're invalid because Navajo language is not needed.' That there's no reason for it. It's not used."


Deschene himself has spoken out about efforts to disqualify him. "These decisions have sent a message to our young saying despite all your accolades, success and everything you've done to help our people, you're not welcome," he said. "It's separating, dividing and isolating ... and the people deserve better."


As of now, Deschene has been officially disqualified as a candidate by Navajo officials after a series of closed-door hearings. However, election officials have refused to remove his name from the ballot, and early voting is already in full swing in the Navajo Nation. A spokesperson for Deschene says it is unlikely the situation will be cleared up before Nov. 4 and that it's unclear what will happen should Deschene win the majority of votes for Navajo Nation president.


"The people get to decide what their standards are," said Deschene. "For me, as an individual, I know I'm a member of the Navajo Nation. I know I'm a member of our people."