Thursday, 13 November 2014

Abu Faour shames more food establishments


BEIRUT: High-profile supermarkets and eateries reeled Thursday from fresh revelations of contaminated food at major establishments in the capital, the latest in a food security scandal that has rocked Lebanon.


Health Minister Wael Abu Faour revealed the names of more restaurants, bakeries and supermarkets selling contaminated food.


The establishments included well-known restaurants like Halabi in Antelias, north of Beirut, Abu Joseph in nearby Jal al-Dib and Hashem in the Kesrouan province.


Abu Faour vowed to push ahead with his crackdown, despite attacks by some of his Cabinet colleagues, who said his move was destructive to the tourism and food industry.


“The campaign is ongoing,” he told a news conference. “We will not stop,” he said, stressing that he would not succumb to intimidation.


The highly anticipated naming provoked a flurry of criticism from ministers accusing Abu Faour of recklessness, while others reiterated their support for the campaign.


Economy Minister Alain Hakim accused Abu Faour of committing “terrorism against the restaurants.”


“It is like shooting ourselves in the head, not even in the foot,” he told reporters before entering Thursday’s Cabinet session.


Tourism Minister Michel Pharaon said he was opposed to Abu Faour’s publicly naming the restaurants, saying the announcement damaged their reputations, even though the problem of contaminated meat might not be their fault, but that of the suppliers.


“The restaurants take from sources that might be themselves the problem. The real inspection should be done on the suppliers,” he said, adding that Lebanon’s restaurants had a great reputation worldwide.


MP Walid Jumblatt, who has stood by Abu Faour over the past two days, reiterated his support in a tweet saying the initiative was meant to protect consumers.


“It is a shame that some ministers did not support the cause of proper food and stand with the interest of the citizen,” he tweeted. “It is a must to continue this action and have strict measures against the various lobbies destroying our health.”


Meanwhile, the Internal Security Forces said that all the establishments listed by Abu Faour Tuesday had since pledged to stop selling the products in question until the situation was legally resolved.


The food security scandal was the hottest topic on the Cabinet’s agenda. The government ordered the formation of a ministerial committee on food safety, which will include Hakim, Pharaon and Abu Faour. The committee is tasked with reaching an agreement on how to deal with the matter.



Judge gives alleged Hezbollah member 18 months in prison


Judge gives alleged Hezbollah member 18 months in prison


A Peruvian judge has ordered held for 18 months for investigation a Lebanese man who entered the country with false...



Berri wants food scandal away from hubbub


Berri wants food scandal away from hubbub


Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri said the law should take its course in the food security scandal uncovered by Health...



Lebanon in need of food safety infrastructure


CAIRO: Regulating food safety in Lebanon should not come at the cost of damaging business interests, experts in the field of food security said Thursday. Rather, future policies should strike a balance.


Weighing in on the latest high-profile food industry scandal that has dominated Lebanese headlines since Tuesday, when Health Minister Wael Abu Faour publicly named establishments discovered to be selling contaminated goods, senior specialists in the field said that despite the ministry’s clampdown, Lebanon has a long way to go before it can boast a healthy food industry.


“Sanctions should be used, but as a last resort,” said Fatima Hashem, senior nutrition and consumer protection officer for the Food and Agriculture Organization.


The experts, who said safety was the main food-related issue plaguing Lebanon, spoke to The Daily Star on the sidelines of a regional workshop organized by the FAO for journalists in Cairo’s Marriot Hotel, covering the issue of malnutrition in the region.


Abu Faour has faced criticism from his colleagues in the Cabinet, notable Economy Minister Alain Hakim and Tourism Minister Michel Pharaon, who saw his move to name the supermarkets, bakeries and restaurants that are violating health codes – including by selling expired products such as meat and poultry – as destructive.


Abu Faour, meanwhile, appears determined to carry on with tough measures against violators, saying he would ask the Interior Ministry to shut them down until they complied with regulations.


Hashem explained that food-related violations in Lebanon were so commonplace for numerous reasons, including a lack of human resources to carry out regular inspections – Abu Faour’s nationwide campaign was unprecedented – and largely outmoded legislation governing food security.


“There aren’t enough inspectors to go to local outlets and inspect regularly,” she said. “And the method of inspection should be based on risk analysis, a more rational system, which is also not yet there. The numbers are not enough and the training needs to be better.”


Hashem said Lebanese laws regulating the food sector also needed to be updated so they took industry and consumer health considerations into account. “The issue is you need to protect the health of the consumer, and there are ways to work with the industry to do that. They could be your best allies in implementing food safety measures. So [in such a system] closing down businesses should be the last thing done.”


Ayoub al-Jawaldeh, regional adviser in nutrition for the WHO, was more categorical in his take: “Expired is expired. It means it’s not fit for human consumption and illegal, and [it is] the responsibility of the government to hold these [violators] accountable.”


In order to improve food safety in Lebanon, he said, the Health Ministry must strengthen legislation and enforce implementation, with close monitoring through the creation of specialized units that oversee all stages in the production chain, “from the farm to the fork.”


“But the Health Ministry can’t do it alone,” he said, emphasizing the collaborative work required with municipalities and other ministries to get the job done. He also recommended the formation of an independent monitoring body, similar to the Food and Drug Organization.


Hashem noted that despite the recent publicity, interest among Lebanese officials to regulate food safety began four years ago when serious efforts were made to modernize then-archaic laws.


“Modernizing a system to improve food safety takes time and takes a lot of investment. To abide by regulations you need a certain [infrastructural] setup,” Hashem said. “You need to have electricity all the time so that perishables do not go to waste.”


She commended the efforts being made by the Health Ministry to address food safety across the country, but warned “it is not yet enough.”


“It’s not because an enterprise is a well-known name that they are better in relation to knowledge about food safety or about what it takes, “ she said, referring to big name supermarkets and restaurants implicated by Abu Faour. “They need training, they need to know that there are staff from an independent body that is checking on them to see where their problems are.”


But, Hashem added, the latest scandal did not imply that Lebanon is worse off then its regional counterparts. “The consumer in Lebanon is highly aware about food safety issues, and a small incident has the ability to produce a large echo.”



Lebanon in need of food safety infrastructure


CAIRO: Regulating food safety in Lebanon should not come at the cost of damaging business interests, experts in the field of food security said Thursday. Rather, future policies should strike a balance.


Weighing in on the latest high-profile food industry scandal that has dominated Lebanese headlines since Tuesday, when Health Minister Wael Abu Faour publicly named establishments discovered to be selling contaminated goods, senior specialists in the field said that despite the ministry’s clampdown, Lebanon has a long way to go before it can boast a healthy food industry.


“Sanctions should be used, but as a last resort,” said Fatima Hashem, senior nutrition and consumer protection officer for the Food and Agriculture Organization.


The experts, who said safety was the main food-related issue plaguing Lebanon, spoke to The Daily Star on the sidelines of a regional workshop organized by the FAO for journalists in Cairo’s Marriot Hotel, covering the issue of malnutrition in the region.


Abu Faour has faced criticism from his colleagues in the Cabinet, notable Economy Minister Alain Hakim and Tourism Minister Michel Pharaon, who saw his move to name the supermarkets, bakeries and restaurants that are violating health codes – including by selling expired products such as meat and poultry – as destructive.


Abu Faour, meanwhile, appears determined to carry on with tough measures against violators, saying he would ask the Interior Ministry to shut them down until they complied with regulations.


Hashem explained that food-related violations in Lebanon were so commonplace for numerous reasons, including a lack of human resources to carry out regular inspections – Abu Faour’s nationwide campaign was unprecedented – and largely outmoded legislation governing food security.


“There aren’t enough inspectors to go to local outlets and inspect regularly,” she said. “And the method of inspection should be based on risk analysis, a more rational system, which is also not yet there. The numbers are not enough and the training needs to be better.”


Hashem said Lebanese laws regulating the food sector also needed to be updated so they took industry and consumer health considerations into account. “The issue is you need to protect the health of the consumer, and there are ways to work with the industry to do that. They could be your best allies in implementing food safety measures. So [in such a system] closing down businesses should be the last thing done.”


Ayoub al-Jawaldeh, regional adviser in nutrition for the WHO, was more categorical in his take: “Expired is expired. It means it’s not fit for human consumption and illegal, and [it is] the responsibility of the government to hold these [violators] accountable.”


In order to improve food safety in Lebanon, he said, the Health Ministry must strengthen legislation and enforce implementation, with close monitoring through the creation of specialized units that oversee all stages in the production chain, “from the farm to the fork.”


“But the Health Ministry can’t do it alone,” he said, emphasizing the collaborative work required with municipalities and other ministries to get the job done. He also recommended the formation of an independent monitoring body, similar to the Food and Drug Organization.


Hashem noted that despite the recent publicity, interest among Lebanese officials to regulate food safety began four years ago when serious efforts were made to modernize then-archaic laws.


“Modernizing a system to improve food safety takes time and takes a lot of investment. To abide by regulations you need a certain [infrastructural] setup,” Hashem said. “You need to have electricity all the time so that perishables do not go to waste.”


She commended the efforts being made by the Health Ministry to address food safety across the country, but warned “it is not yet enough.”


“It’s not because an enterprise is a well-known name that they are better in relation to knowledge about food safety or about what it takes, “ she said, referring to big name supermarkets and restaurants implicated by Abu Faour. “They need training, they need to know that there are staff from an independent body that is checking on them to see where their problems are.”


But, Hashem added, the latest scandal did not imply that Lebanon is worse off then its regional counterparts. “The consumer in Lebanon is highly aware about food safety issues, and a small incident has the ability to produce a large echo.”



Businesses caught off guard by Abu Faour’s food blacklist


BEIRUT: Several of Lebanon’s leading food establishments are scrambling to handle the fallout following another news conference by Health Minister Wael Abu Faour, in which he named more restaurants and markets that do not meet the national health standards. The country has witnessed confusion and outrage since Tuesday, when Abu Faour began announcing the results of a monthlong investigation into over 1,000 restaurants and supermarkets carried out by the Health Ministry.


The list of food establishments included household names like Roadster, TSC Mega, Spinneys and Monoprix. More names are expected to be released in the coming days.


Abu Faour’s decision to announce the results of the laboratory tests live on television, as opposed to notifying them in question directly, has drawn criticism from some quarters.


Christine Khoury, head of marketing at supermarket TSC Mega, said her company was caught off guard by Abu Faour’s announcement.


“We were all shocked,” Khoury said. “I don’t know why they are doing this now and why is this happening ... We’ve been operating for six years. We’ve never had any issue of anybody being poisoned.”


She said TSC Mega bought its meat from a variety of government-certified sources, and called into question the certification process.


According to Khoury, health checks by the government are routine, but this is the first time the ministry has gone directly to the media with the results.


Several Cabinet members also took issue with the manner in which Abu Faour released the information. Economy Minister Alain Hakim called the Health Minister’s methods ‘terrorizing.’


Head of the Lebanese Franchise Association Charles Arbid expressed outrage during a news conference.


“We want to know why the minister failed to send a warning to the violating restaurants and supermarkets before accusing them of poisoning the Lebanese,” he said. “If these allegations were true, then half of the citizens would be dead and the remaining in hospitals.”


Abu Faour hit back at his critics before announcing the establishments on the second list Thursday morning, stating that he would not submit to intimidation.


“We expected a vengeful reaction over our spoiled food battle,” he told reporters. “[But] the campaign is ongoing ... we will not stop.”


The head of Beirut Chambers of Commerce Mohammed Choucair also criticized the way in which Abu Faour had announced the list, saying that a smear campaign against franchises could put hundreds of jobs at risk.


“Why didn’t anyone say anything about these issues 15 years ago?” he said. “I don’t want to deny that these restaurants have failed to meet the criteria, but the minister could have done it in a more tactful way, and without damaging the reputation of these establishments.”


A source at Monoprix’s Head Office, who could not give his name as he was not permitted to speak with the media, said that the French retail chain was startled by the revelations.


“We were surprised, just like everyone else,” the source said. “[Monoprix] is preparing a response ... The CEO will issue a formal press statement with all the details.”


The source commended the Health Ministry for announcing the results to the public. “It’s the public’s right,” he said.


Abu Faour said the chicken escalope at Monoprix’s Jnah branch was “not up to standards.”


According to the source, Monoprix receives its chicken from a number of places that are all government certified, and they expect it to be sanitary when it arrives.


“We have a few different places that we get our chicken from,” the source said. “Monoprix cannot test 1,000 or 2,000 kg of chicken every day. We expect it to be up to standard from the source.”


One high-profile restaurant named on the list was the popular Roadster Diner. The 16-year-old chain has 13 stores in Beirut and its suburbs, and is dear to many people.


The company issued a press release on its Facebook page Wednesday evening in which it stressed that it was committed to “food safety and quality.” The statement emphasized that Roadster had ISO 22000 certification and certification from the Lebanese Association for Food Safety.


Arbid, the head of the Lebanese Franchise Association, questioned the methods used by the government, as in his opinion, “all or most of the franchise restaurants that were named by the minister have ISO certificates for excellent quality.”


Roadster’s senior brand manager Sahar Dumyati said that the restaurant was currently collaborating with the ministry on how they could move forward. Unlike other companies, Dumyati said they were not caught off guard by the list.


“All [this] time we’ve been collaborating with the Health Ministry; this is not a surprise,” Dumyati told The Daily Star. “This is routine. The twist that’s added is the media exposure. “


Dumyati could not give further details on what steps Roadster would be taking, but she did say she was somewhat ‘concerned’ about Abu Faour’s comment Thursday that the Interior Ministry would begin taking action against the listed restaurants and supermarkets.


There has been a notable amount of support for Roadster on social media, and the comment feed under their press release had amassed 2,000 likes at the time of print.


“You’ll see a balance [on social media],” Dumyati said. “This is where the trust and credibility of the brand comes in


“You have the brand bashers, and the brand defenders.”



The Color Of Politics: How Did Red And Blue States Come To Be?



NBC employees change Nebraska to red in the electoral map of the United States in 2008. All the TV news operations, including NBC News, settled on red for Republicans and blue for Democrats in 2000.i i



NBC employees change Nebraska to red in the electoral map of the United States in 2008. All the TV news operations, including NBC News, settled on red for Republicans and blue for Democrats in 2000. Mary Altaffer/AP hide caption



itoggle caption Mary Altaffer/AP

NBC employees change Nebraska to red in the electoral map of the United States in 2008. All the TV news operations, including NBC News, settled on red for Republicans and blue for Democrats in 2000.



NBC employees change Nebraska to red in the electoral map of the United States in 2008. All the TV news operations, including NBC News, settled on red for Republicans and blue for Democrats in 2000.


Mary Altaffer/AP


Americans grow up knowing their colors are red, white and blue. It's right there in the flag, right there in the World Series bunting and on those floats every fourth of July.


So when did we become a nation of red states and blue states? And what do they mean when they say a state is turning purple?


Painting whole states with a broad brush bothers a lot of people, and if you're one of them you may want to blame the media. We've been using these designations rather vigorously for the last half-dozen election cycles or so as a quick way to describe the vote in given state in a given election, or its partisan tendencies over a longer period.


It got started on TV, the original electronic visual, when NBC, the first all-color network, unveiled an illuminated map – snazzy for its time – in 1976. John Chancellor was the NBC election night anchor who explained how states were going to be blue if they voted for incumbent Republican Gerald Ford, red if they voted for Democratic challenger Jimmy Carter.


That arrangement was consistent with the habit of many texts and reference books, which tended to use blue for Republicans in part because blue was the color of the Union in the Civil War. Blue is also typically associated with the more conservative parties in Europe and elsewhere.


As the other TV operations went to full color, they too added vivid maps to their election night extravaganzas. But they didn't agree on a color scheme, so viewers switching between channels might see Ronald Reagan's landslide turning the landscape blue on NBC and CBS but red on ABC.


The confusion persisted until 2000, when the coloring of states for one party of the other dragged on well past election night. As people were more interested in the red-blue maps than ever, the need for consistency across media outlets became paramount. And as the conversation about the disputed election continued, referring to states that voted for George W. Bush as "red states" rather than "Republican states" (and those voting for Democrat Al Gore as "blue states") seemed increasingly natural.


And it never went away. Instead, it became a staple of political discourse, not just in the media but in academic circles and popular conversation as well.


By the next presidential election, the red-blue language was so common as to be a metaphor for partisanship. That provided a convenient target for the most memorable speech of that election cycle, the 2004 keynote address at the Democratic National Convention in Boston, delivered by a young senatorial candidate from Illinois named Barack Obama.


"The pundits, the pundits like to slice and dice our country into red states and blue states," he said. "Red states for Republicans, blue states for Democrats. But I've got news for them, too — we worship an awesome God in the blue states and we don't like federal agents poking around in our libraries in the red states."


Of course, that did not stop "the pundits" or anyone else from using these catchy labels. If anything, the practice has become more universal.


Not a few Americans see this as a symptom of a real disease in the body politic, an imbalance in favor of conflict that makes compromise more difficult.


Painting whole states with an ideologically broad brush is also offensive to many. No liberal in Idaho needs to be told that state leans conservative, just as conservatives in Minnesota are fully aware theirs was the only state not tinted for Ronald Reagan in 1984.


But being on the minor-fraction side of the party balance does not make these citizens less Idahoan or less Minnesotan. On the contrary, they may be among the fiercest loyalists of either state.



No one thinks the red or blue designation makes a state politically single-minded. But the message sent by such media-driven characterizations is not without consequence.


Bill Bishop, the Texas-based writer who co-authored the influential book The Big Sort in 2004, says political affiliation is a powerful part of the allure certain communities have for Americans seeking a compatible home.


"All of this is a shorthand, right? So a 'blue community' is a shorthand not only for politics but for a way of life..." says Bishop.


And for many people, that way of life includes a sorting out by political affinity.


"We thought at first that this was all lifestyle, but the more I talked to people the more I talked to people who said it was a conscious decision to go to a Democratic area or a Republican area."


Which may mean the red and blue labels will be even harder for the media to resist using in the years ahead.



Is The Election Over Yet?



Republican candidate for Arizona Congressional District 2 Martha McSally speaks at a news conference the morning after the election. McSally's race against Democrat Ron Barber is so close it triggered a recount.i i



Republican candidate for Arizona Congressional District 2 Martha McSally speaks at a news conference the morning after the election. McSally's race against Democrat Ron Barber is so close it triggered a recount. Ross D. Franklin/AP hide caption



itoggle caption Ross D. Franklin/AP

Republican candidate for Arizona Congressional District 2 Martha McSally speaks at a news conference the morning after the election. McSally's race against Democrat Ron Barber is so close it triggered a recount.



Republican candidate for Arizona Congressional District 2 Martha McSally speaks at a news conference the morning after the election. McSally's race against Democrat Ron Barber is so close it triggered a recount.


Ross D. Franklin/AP


The election is over right? Republicans added control the U.S. Senate and padded their majority in the House.


So the big drama of the campaign may have subsided, but there is still a handful of congressional contests are still up in the air.


There are runoff elections scheduled. A couple of races that are still too close to call. And there's at least one official recount coming.


U.S. Senate Races



Congressman Bill Cassidy is in a tight runoff election against Democratic incumbent Sen. Mary Landrieu.i i



Congressman Bill Cassidy is in a tight runoff election against Democratic incumbent Sen. Mary Landrieu. Melinda Deslatte/AP hide caption



itoggle caption Melinda Deslatte/AP

Congressman Bill Cassidy is in a tight runoff election against Democratic incumbent Sen. Mary Landrieu.



Congressman Bill Cassidy is in a tight runoff election against Democratic incumbent Sen. Mary Landrieu.


Melinda Deslatte/AP


In Louisiana — a place where politics are always interesting — three-term Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu finds herself in a runoff against Republican congressman Bill Cassidy, because both failed to get more than the 50% required to claim victory last Tuesday.


Even though control of the Senate doesn't hang on the outcome, their battle now goes into an extra month of overtime.


The TV attack ads are back too. The Landrieu campaign introduced a new one this week, as did the National Republican Senatorial Committee on behalf of the challenger.


The other Senate seat that's been up in the air is in Alaska, where incumbent Democrat Mark Begich faced Republican Dan Sullivan. The Associated Press has called the race for Sullivan. But Begich hasn't conceded.



The Associated Press has called the Alaska Senate race for challenger Dan Sullivan. But incumbent Sen. Mark Begich, above, has not conceded.i i



The Associated Press has called the Alaska Senate race for challenger Dan Sullivan. But incumbent Sen. Mark Begich, above, has not conceded. J. Scott Applewhite/AP hide caption



itoggle caption J. Scott Applewhite/AP

The Associated Press has called the Alaska Senate race for challenger Dan Sullivan. But incumbent Sen. Mark Begich, above, has not conceded.



The Associated Press has called the Alaska Senate race for challenger Dan Sullivan. But incumbent Sen. Mark Begich, above, has not conceded.


J. Scott Applewhite/AP


On Capitol Hill Wednesday, incoming Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell posed with 10 new GOP Senators elect. He's looking for the number of newcomers to increase. "We're excited to have a great bunch here and we hope their going to be joined by Bill Cassidy and Dan Sullivan shortly," he said. Sullivan, having claimed victory, has since flown to DC to begin with new member orientation.


House Races


There are two in Louisiana, congressional districts 5 and 6, where run-offs will decide the winner. The latter involves Democrat Edwin Edwards, 87, who has a resume that includes congress, the governorship, AND 8 years in federal prison for corruption.


In Arizona, the battle for the 2nd district is heading for an automatic recount. It features incumbent Democrat Ron Barber, a former aide to congresswoman Gabby Giffords who was shot and wounded along with Giffords by a gunman in January 2011. Barber trails Republican Martha McSally by just 133 votes. Nearly all of the votes have been tallies, and state law requires a recount if the margin is less than 200 votes.


Finally, there are two undeclared races in California. In the 7th district, near Sacramento, and the 16th, which includes parts of Fresno.


Both feature incumbent Democrats who currently hold very narrow leads.


So election day has come and gone.


We just don't know yet when it will all be officially...and finally...and mercifully over.



Hezbollah: Aoun a consensus candidate


BEIRUT: Hezbollah said Thursday it considered Free Patriotic Movement leader Michel Aoun a consensus presidential candidate, as the international community pressed the country’s political class to end the nearly six-month vacuum in the top Christian seat.


“[Aoun] has full agency over his decisions and has no foreign agenda ... and he heads the largest Christian bloc and he might be the only [real] leader of Christians in Lebanon and the Middle East,” said Hussein Khalil, a political aide to Hezbollah chief Sayyed Hasan Nasrallah.


Khalil went on to describe Aoun as the “epitome of the patriotic leader.”


“If we want to agree on a person to fill the presidential seat, he should be a man like General Aoun. This is a conviction that we will not change until further notice,” he added.


Khalil spoke following talks with Aoun at his Rabieh residence. Khalil was accompanied by Wafiq Safa, Hezbollah’s top security official. Also attending the talks was Foreign Minister Gebran Bassil, Aoun’s son-in-law.


The meeting came hours after Aoun’s Change and Reform bloc challenged before the Constitutional Council the extension law endorsed by Parliament last week.


“The challenge has constitutional and national reasons,” MP Ibrahim Kanaan told reporters on his way out of the council’s building.


“As for constitutional reasons, we ask: What does democracy mean? It means elections and transition of power, what remains of democracy if these two values were undermined?” he said.


Last week, Parliament endorsed a law to extend its own mandate for another two years and seven months, after a similar move in 2013, when it renewed its term for 17 months.


Ninety-five out of the 97 MPs attending the session, including those from Hezbollah, voted yes, citing “exceptional circumstances’ resulting from the deteriorating security situation in Tripoli, Arsal and other areas in the country.


Lawmakers from Aoun’s bloc and the Kataeb Party boycotted the vote in opposition.


Kanaan dismissed the pretext of Lebanon’s deteriorating security based on which the extension law was passed.


“Where is the destructive war based on which the international law defines exceptional circumstances? Do events in Arsal and Tripoli, where the situation is getting back to normal, amount to a destructive war?”


Khalil described divergent stances between Hezbollah and Aoun over extension of Parliament’s term as a “trivial matter.”


“It indicates that neither we impose our convictions on our allies nor our allies accept that we impose on them our convictions.”


According to a Constitutional expert, if the Constitutional Council accepted the challenge, then the Lebanese government would have to hold elections.


“If the council accepts the challenge after Nov. 20, the day Parliament’s term expires, then the government should hold parliamentary elections within three months in line with Article 25 of the Constitution,” the expert said, requesting to remain anonymous.


Speaking to The Daily Star, the expert added that MPs could file another extension draft law if the challenge was accepted before the expiry of Parliament’s term.


The Constitutional Council has 30 days to look into the challenge, if no decision was made during this period, the extension law will automatically become valid.


Former President Michel Sleiman and Aoun’s bloc challenged the first extension law before the council, but the challenge was not discussed after Shiite and Druze council members, loyal to Speaker Nabih Berri and MP Walid Jumblatt, boycotted its sessions.


In a news conference Wednesday, Issam Suleiman, the head of the council, pledged that the body would meet the quorum this time to discuss the extension law.


Lebanese Forces leader Samir Geagea said his group’s support for the extension law was not influenced by Saudi Arabia, which he visited last month.


“I did not raise the issue of extension with [Saudi Foreign Minister] Prince Saud al-Faisal, and Saudi officials care the least about whether extension happened,” Geagea told LBCI television station.


Meanwhile, the U.N. Security Council on Wednesday also urged Parliament to swiftly elect a president to boost stability.


The 15-member council “expressed concern at the prolonged vacancy in the office of the presidency with a view to preserving the stability and the unity of Lebanon,” said Australian Ambassador Gary Quinlan, whose country chairs the council.


The top U.N. body requested that Parliament moves “without delay” to a vote and said Lebanon’s politicians must show the “flexibility and sense of urgency” needed to agree on a successor to Sleiman.


For his part, U.S Ambassador to Lebanon David Hale reiterated calls for electing a president as soon as possible.


“We have called on Lebanon’s Parliament to elect a president as soon as possible, and in accordance with the country’s Constitution,” Hale said during a speech at the American Lebanese Chamber of Commerce.


“The election of a president is a decision entirely for the Lebanese to take, but take it, they must,” the ambassador added.


Hale later repeated the same calls after visiting Maronite Patriarch Beshara Rai, also urging Lebanese leaders to hold parliamentary elections as soon as possible after the “regrettable, recent decision to postpone parliamentary elections and extend the term of the current Parliament again.”



Father of Australian jihadi in Syria wants son to come home


TRIPOLI, Lebanon: Pictures of Islamist fighters in Syria proudly holding the severed heads of enemy combatants may have become increasingly common, but they have not yet lost their power to shock. For Mamdouh Elomar, however, one image in particular was even more shocking than the others: the man displaying the decapitated heads was his son, Mohammad. Elomar, 60, is a wealthy Lebanese-Australian. A short but stocky man, he has passed on his stoutness to his sons, all three of whom are boxing champions like their father. But despite his outward “Tripolitan tough guy” aura, Elomar is kind and charitable.


He recently decided to pay for a shipment of desperately needed hospital supplies to be taken from Australia to Lebanon, and clearly maintains a close connection to Lebanon, and Tripoli in particular. He came to Lebanon a little over three weeks ago to oversee the delivery of the shipment, provided by the Australian Arab Association.


“I want to make sure the help goes to the poor,” he said. “The aid is meant to go to Lebanese people ... regardless of religion or sect.”


The shipment includes brand new equipment that will be divided between public hospitals in Beirut and Tripoli, including bandages, bedding, theater equipment, wheelchairs, needles, syringes and other supplies that undersupplied Lebanese public hospitals will be happy to receive.


Elomar left Tripoli in 1973 for Australia and now resides in Sydney, the city where he raised his five children. While he speaks English, he appears more comfortable talking in his native Arabic. He now manages hundreds of employees, including two of his sons, between a business in Australia and another in Papau New Guinea.


“[Mohammad] worked for me for 17 or 18 years but then he stopped coming to work,” Elomar said. “I talked to him and he said he didn’t want to work. He used to live with me, but he took his wife and children and left. I started seeing him rarely and I didn’t speak to him much.


“Two years later, we find his photos on TV. Mohammad had joined the Syrian revolution.”


While Elomar said he wasn’t sure which group his son was affiliated with, Australian media claims Mohammad is a member of the notoriously brutal radical group ISIS. Either way, he is wanted as a terrorist by the Australian government.


Mohammad’s uncle is serving a jail term in Australia for conspiring to plot a terrorist attack, while his brother is incarcerated for physically assaulting a police officer during the 2012 Hyde Park riots in Sydney.


Before Mohammad traveled to Syria, his mother tried to coax him into returning home.


His father, on the other hand, has cut off all relations and refuses to speak with his son.


“You feel that the person is different. But if he says it’s none of your business what can you do?” Elomar asked. “Time will teach him, I can only advise him.”


Mohammad does not fit the usual patterns found in the background of foreign jihadis who have made their way to Syria or Iraq.


Growing up, he wasn’t particularly religious, nor did he study Islam or attend an Islamic school, according to his father.


Many foreign jihadis are often loners in their teens or early 20s, whereas Mohammad is 30 and was apparently never short of friends. “As a kid he used to go from school to boxing and he was likeable and had friends at boxing school,” Elomar said. Nor did he cause any serious trouble growing up, as indicated by his clean police record.


What Mohammad’s father does not mention is the Australia-based Shiekh Feiz Mohammad, whom various media reports blame for his son’s brainwashing.


For whatever reason, many youngsters with Arab roots born in countries like Australia have taken up the fight in Syria. “Our sons, the new generation, do not know how things were when we were poor and fleeing from the war in Lebanon,” he said. “I would like to say that Australia is the best country because it protected us.”


Elomar has now cut off contact with his daughter-in-law and grandkids, despite the fact that they only live a 20-minute drive away. He’s unsure if they have police protection, but he says his oldest grandson, aged 9, has no problems at school related to his father’s actions.


Still, he wouldn’t pass up an opportunity to speak to his son if he ever got another chance.


“If I was lucky enough to talk to him, I would advise him to go to the Australian Embassy and turn himself in, then go back to live with his family,” Elomar said. “I would advise him not to die.”



Key witness Hamade to testify at STL next week


BEIRUT: MP Marwan Hamade, who survived an assassination attempt in 2004, will be called to testify Monday at the Special Tribunal for Lebanon to detail the breakdown in relations between former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri and Syrian President Bashar Assad, prosecutors said Thursday. The announcement of Hamade’s testimony came as defense lawyers said they had received from the prosecution evidence linked to Assad’s telephone, as well as testimony by the assassinated Lebanese intelligence chief Wissam Hasan.


The bombshell revelation is the latest twist in the case ahead of the next phase of trial, which will begin next week and will focus on Syria’s role in destabilizing Lebanon ahead of Hariri’s assassination.


“This ghost of the Syrians is coming out of the cupboard,” said Philippe Larochelle, a lawyer for Hussein Oneissi, one of the suspects in the case, arguing that prosecutors had already built their case on reams of telecommunications evidence and had not previously pointed to Syria.


“How are you going to fit the Syrians into this?” he asked.


The STL is tasked with prosecuting the people responsible for the 2005 bombing that killed Hariri as well as 21 others.


The attack brought international opprobrium on the Syrian regime, which was suspected of orchestrating the attack due to the breakdown of relations between Assad and Hariri, especially over the extension of then-President Emile Lahoud’s term and the passage of Resolution 1559 ordering the disarming of Hezbollah and Syria’s departure from Lebanon.


But the STL instead indicted five members of Hezbollah in connection with the attack, and their trial in absentia is ongoing in The Hague.


The second phase of the trial is set to begin next week. In it, prosecutors hope to detail the intricate tracking of the telephones of the suspects, showing their surveillance of Hariri ahead of the assassination.


But the other, more controversial aspect of the second phase of trial is the prosecution’s plan to detail the political context in Lebanon and the deterioration of relations with Syria, in what could be a first step toward expanding the scope of the case and pinpointing a political motive for Hariri’s killing, dragging Syria back into the case.


Thirteen prominent politicians, journalists and advisers to Hariri are set to testify before the STL in the coming weeks on the deterioration of relations with Syria in the six months before the assassination, sparked by his attempts to “strengthen Lebanon’s independence,” said Graeme Cameron, the prosecution’s senior trial counsel.


Cameron said the testimony would show that Syria was “determined” as a result of the breakdown in relations with Hariri “to control Lebanon’s internal affairs and not simply to influence them.”


The testimony will also cover the growing worries of the international community over Syria’s interference, and the evolution of an anti-Syrian opposition that Hariri joined in the months before his killing.


Cameron said the political testimony would help to understand the actions of members of the conspiracy that assassinated Hariri.


Defense lawyer David Young said the Syria evidence represented a “significant sea change in the way the prosecution has put their case.”


Defense lawyers said the prosecution had gone as far as to present a “new theory” against the suspects, saying the new evidence, including statements made by intelligence chief Wissam Hasan before his death, were all but a new track in a case that had appeared for a long time to abandon the Syrian angle.


“This evidence I believe will be of not one whit of help to you,” Larochelle said, addressing the trial judges. “It is just going to taint the whole file, it’s going to invite you to speculation well beyond what the indictment allows you to do.”



Hezbollah’s impunity undermines stability: Hale


BEIRUT: Lebanon will not find stability as long as Hezbollah is strong enough to act with impunity and enforce its will, U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon David Hale said Thursday.


Hale’s remarks came in a speech he gave at the American Lebanese Chamber of Commerce on the threat of ISIS.


“But we all know defeating [ISIS] alone will not restore stability to Lebanon. We all know there are underlying problems,” Hale said. “High on the list of risks is the continued ability of one militia, Hezbollah, to bear arms and act with impunity.”


“So long as that is the case, stability will be absent, and growth impeded,” he added.


Hale said that only national dialogue and the adherence to the Baabda Declaration of 2012, which stipulated Lebanon’s disassociation from the war in Syria, could pave the way for Lebanon’s stability. But until then, Hezbollah’s power remains one of the main obstacles, he said.


Until that dialogue advances, and its principles are not just agreed to but adhered to, the risks to this country’s stability will remain very real, Hale said.


“The security institutions of the state should have the capability, and sole legitimacy to defend Lebanon’s territory,” he added.


“For they alone – and not a militia – are accountable to the people.”


He said decisions of war and peace directly affect every Lebanese citizen, and should thus be made by a constitutional government that is accountable to the people, and not by “a militia accountable to a foreign government.”



Expanding Opportunity and Addressing Unique Challenges Facing Women and Girls of Color

When President Obama founded the White House Council on Women and Girls (CWG) within the first two months of taking office, he charged us with working to address inequalities and barriers facing women and girls in our schools, workplaces, and throughout American life. And as women’s role in society and our economy continues to evolve and grow, so too has the importance of ensuring that all women and girls succeed, including women and girls of color who often face compounded disparities.


A CWG report released yesterday delves into the inequities and distinct challenges facing women of color, while examining some of the efforts underway to close unfair gaps in educational outcomes, pay, career opportunity, health disparities, and more.


Since its inception, the CWG has focused on issues which disproportionately affect women of color. As part of this ongoing effort, the CWG is convening a Working Group to bring together policy staff from the White House and across the federal agencies, with advocates and experts from around the country. Together, this group will focus on issues including education, economic security, health, criminal and juvenile justice, violence, and research and data collection. By detailing both the progress we have made and the challenges that still remain, this report should serve both as a reminder of what is possible and as a call to action to do so much more.


read more


#AskDrH: The President's Science Advisor Is Answering Your Questions on Climate Change

Watch on YouTube


Got questions about climate change? Ask the President's science advisor.


Dr. John P. Holdren, Director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, wants to answer any questions that you have about climate change -- what it means, how bad it actually is, and what we can do to fight it.


Starting today, ask Dr. Holdren your questions on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, or Vine using the hashtag #AskDrH -- and he'll answer some of them on camera.


read more


Hezbollah: Aoun is a consensus candidate


Hezbollah officials to visit Aoun


Top Hezbollah officials will visit Thursday Free Patriotic Movement leader Michel Aoun at his residence in Rabieh,...



Getting Ready for Open Enrollment:

Ed note: This is cross-posted from the Department of Health and Human Services' blog.



With just two days to go until the start of Open Enrollment, I want to share with you what we've been doing at the Department of Health and Human Services to expand access to quality, affordable coverage to more people and to lay the groundwork for a successful Open Enrollment.


First, we're committed to improving the consumer experience.


We've listened to feedback and have put that learning into practice. Most consumers who come back to HealthCare.gov to renew their coverage will find about 90% of their application is pre-populated, based on answers from last year. Consumers who are renewing coverage, as well as consumers shopping for coverage for the first time, will have 25% more options to choose from on average. That means consumers can shop and find a more affordable plan that better meets their needs. And we've added 1,000 representatives to our 24-hour call center to answer questions and help consumers get and stay covered.


We also understand that it's our job to protect consumers' security and we take that responsibility seriously.


We've tested and retested our systems, putting ourselves through some of the industry's most stringent protocols to ensure we're taking the steps necessary to safeguard consumers' personal information. We've enhanced our cybersecurity team with experts from the public and private sector to raise the bar on security. And we'll be focused every day on what more we can do to improve our ability to respond to cybersecurity events quickly and effectively if needed.


If you signed up for Marketplace coverage during last Open Enrollment:


We encourage you to come back to HealthCare.gov, reach out to the call center, or meet with an in-person assister to make sure you choose the plan that's right for you and get the best financial help available.


Starting November 15, if you're renewing your coverage, you should log into your account.


By doing so, you can make sure your household income and other information is up-to-date, compare your current plan with other plans available in your area, select the plan that best meets your needs and budget, and choose a plan by December 15 for coverage starting January 1.


If you're shopping for coverage for the first time, Open Enrollment runs from November 15 to February 15. Your coverage can start as soon as January 1 if you sign up by December 15.


All consumers should visit HealthCare.gov or reach out to our 24/7 call center with any questions: 1-800-318-2596 (TTY 1-855-889-4325). Information about in-person assistance is available at localhelp.healthcare.gov.


Join the millions of Americans who now have access to quality, affordable coverage: Sign up between November 15 and February 15.


Letters to the President: The Dicksons and the Affordable Care Act

Every day, thousands of Americans write President Obama about the issues that matter most to them -- and my job is to help sort through them. This post is the first in a series that will help highlight the stories of Americans who have written the President about the Affordable Care Act and what it means to them. Starting November 15, you can visit HealthCare.gov to shop for and enroll in a plan that works for you.


The voices of people across America inform the President and give him invaluable perspective on the progress we've made -- as well as the work we've got left to do. If you want to write the President yourself, you can do that here.


“Because we now have access to affordable healthcare, we have now signed a long-term lease to open a retail business in Georgetown, Texas.”


--Russ and Linda Dickson



President Barack Obama and First Lady Michelle Obama meet with Texans who wrote letters to the President about the Affordable Care Act (ACA), at the Lyndon B. Johnson (LBJ) Presidential Library and Museum in Austin, Texas, April 10, 2014. Participants inc

President Barack Obama and First Lady Michelle Obama meet with Texans who wrote letters to the President about the Affordable Care Act (ACA), at the Lyndon B. Johnson (LBJ) Presidential Library and Museum in Austin, Texas, April 10, 2014. Participants include: Linda Dickson (52) with Russ Dickson (60) [husband] (antique store owners). (Official White House Photo by Pete Souza)




read more


Jumblatt aide remains in prison despite court order


BEIRUT: A Lebanese court ordered the release Thursday of Bahij Abu Hamzeh, the businessman and former aide of MP Walid Jumblatt, after the maximum holding period for a misdemeanor expired.


But he will remain in prison over another case, judicial sources told The Daily Star.


Abu Hamzeh had been in custody for more than four months, the maximum for committing a misdemeanor. As a result, he was released over a breach of trust and embezzlement case filed by Jumblatt.


The lawsuits came after a dramatic deterioration of relations between Jumblatt and Abu Hamzeh, who used to run the MP’s real estate endeavors and manage his private properties for more than two decades.


The second lawsuit accused Abu Hamzeh of intentionally mismanaging Jumblatt’s properties with the purpose of achieving personal gain. For this case, which was issued recently, Abu Hamzeh will remain in custody until a sentence is issued or until the end of his mandatory custody period.


In addition to the two lawsuits, Hamzeh had also faced charges by the Safa football club that he had been running for years. However, those charges were dropped Monday.


Investigative Judge Ghassan Oueidat had issued the indictment in the second case against Abu Hamzeh also on Monday which carries a prison sentence of between three months and three years.


The judge had earlier set Hamzeh’s bail at LL20 million ($13,214) for the first case. But his lawyer filed an appeal which was heard and won Thursday, allowing the defendant to be released in that case without paying bail.


The PSP leader had earlier said he was the victim of “organized fraud,” and accused Abu Hamzeh and another businessman of taking advantage of the fact that he was busy with politics and social obligations in order to dupe him.


Abu Hamzeh has been in jail since April, first for the Safa case, then for Jumblatt’s lawsuit.


He is a chemical engineer and a Middle East agent for the U.S. pharmaceutical company Upjohn, and had been living in Paris until 1987, when Jumblatt requested him to return home and manage his properties.


He is also the former head of the Association of Oil Importing Companies.



ISIS leader urges attacks in Saudi Arabia: speech


ISIS releases audio of chief Baghdadi after death rumor


ISIS on Thursday released an audio recording it said was of its chief Abu Bakr Baghdadi, days after an airstrike on...



Hezbollah’s 'impunity' undermines stability: Hale



BEIRUT: Lebanon will not find stability as long as Hezbollah is strong enough to act with impunity and enforce its will, U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon David Hale said Thursday.


Hale’s remarks came in a speech he gave at the American Lebanese Chamber of Commerce, which focused on the threat of ISIS.


“But we all know defeating [ISIS] alone will not restore stability to Lebanon. We all know there are underlying problems,” Hale said. “High on the list of risks is the continued ability of one militia, Hezbollah, to bear arms and act with impunity.”


“So long as that is the case, stability will be absent, and growth impeded.”


Hale said that only national dialogue and the adherence to the Baabda Declaration can pave the way for Lebanon’s stability. But until then, Hezbollah’s power remains one of the main obstacles.


Until that dialogue advances, and its principles are not just agreed to but adhered to, the risks to this country’s stability will remain very real, Hale said.


“The security institutions of the state should have the capability, and sole legitimacy, to defend Lebanon’s territory,” he added. “For they alone – and not a militia – are accountable to the people."


He said the decisions of war and peace directly affect every Lebanese citizen, and should thus be held by a constitutional government accountable to the people, and “not to a militia accountable to a foreign government.”



Advertisement



US says Iraq remains priority over Syria in ISIS fight


Comments


Your feedback is important to us!


We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.


Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.


Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (http://bit.ly/vDisqus)


comments powered by Disqus


Hezbollah officials to visit Aoun


FPM files Parliament extension appeal


The Change and Reform bloc challenges the law approved by Parliament last week to extend its own mandate by more than...



Security forces foil kidnapping in Masnaa


PFLP-GC steps up Lebanese border presence


A security source told The Daily Star that the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command has...



Roadster says food of the 'highest quality'


Contaminated food charges leave a bad taste


Lebanese expressed mixed reactions Wednesday as the country continued to reel from the shock of being told that some...



Ahmad Hariri defends extension, blasts rivals


BEIRUT: Future Movement Secretary General Ahmad Hariri defended his party's lawmakers who voted last week to approve Parliament's extension by more than two years, telling AUB student supporters that holding elections during a presidential vacuum was never an option.


“The reason [Future] voted for the extension is not that we are afraid of elections as some people claim,” Hariri told a crowd of student leaders and supporters from AUB Thursday.


“But in the case of extension, our position was clear from the beginning, which is that oppose conducting elections during presidential vacuum.”


Hariri also attacked his political rivals Hezbollah, Amal and the Free Patriotic Movement, accusing them of obstruction.


“There is a political faction that wants to drag the country into total void, while it aims at amending the Constitution and achieve the tripartite power sharing formula,” he said.


A tripartite formula calls for a 33-33-33 distribution of Christians, Shiites and Sunnis in Parliament. The current system, based on the country’s 1943 National Pact, give half the seats to Christians, and the other half to Muslims.


“In parallel, another faction wants to generalize vacuum, and extend its duration, according to the logic that gives two choices: either him becoming president or keeping the state without a head,” he said in reference to FPM chief Michel Aoun.


Hariri’s meeting with the students was held at the old Kantari presidential palace, and came five days before AUB student council elections.



Police disperse Sidon industrial workers protesting blackout



SIDON, Lebanon: Police used force Thursday to disperse workers and factory owners blocking the main highway between Sidon and Tyre in south Lebanon to protest against the government’s failure to repair electricity cables.


The five-day power outage, due to electricity workers' recent decision to stop all maintenance work, caused a total blackout in Sidon’s industrial zone, security sources told The Daily Star.


The protesters burned tires, blocking traffic in both directions between the two main coastal cities for several hours Thursday morning before police unblocked the vital road by force, the sources said.


The blackout, which grounded businesses and factories for the past five days, occurred after the main cable supplying the industrial zone south of Sidon caught fire.


Striking EDL contract workers had adamantly refused to answer queries to repair the cable, paralyzing work at dozens of factories, the sources added.


EDL contract workers said last week they will stop all maintenance work across Lebanon, cautioning that it might result in major power disruptions.


Until then, the contract workers were carrying out maintenance and repair work on the electricity network despite their three-month long strike over labor issues. Their decision to escalate their protest was meant to prove that their work was essential for the country to function.


Many of the contract workers' critics accuse them of being lazy, but the workers say they are tired of being taken for granted.


EDL’s contract workers have been on strike and camping out at the company’s headquarters since August to demand full-time employment. They have been employed by three private service providers since 2012, and the companies’ contracts will end in 2016.


The strike started after EDL announced it would only employ 897 of the nearly 2,000 contract workers.



Advertisement



FPM files Parliament extension appeal


BEIRUT: The Change and Reform bloc challenged Thursday the law approved by Parliament last week to extend its own mandate by more than two years, insisting that poor security was no excuse to justify the move.


“We submitted an appeal against the extension law at the Constitutional Council,” Free Patriotic Movement MP Ibrahim Kanaan told reporters from outside the council building.


“The appeal has constitutional and legal reasons, and the constitutional one is that democracy means elections and change in authorities.”


Kanaan said that extension runs counter to democratic principles and contradicts the constitution, adding that no country in the world would allow its legislators to extend their terms if the decision was up to the people.


Kanaan underlined that Lebanon is not at war, and the security conditions are not bad enough to prevent elections. And if there was a rare case an extension was needed, there is no justification to extend the term by two and a half years.


“We have not lost our faith in the state and the institution,” Kanaan said, “And our visit to the Constitutional Council is proof despite what is being said about the council and the other main institutions in the country.”


Last week, Parliament approved a law to extend its own mandate for another two years and seven months, after a similar move in 2013, when it renewed its term for 17 months.


Ninety-five out of the 97 MPs attending the session voted yes, with the Free Patriotic Movement and Kataeb Party boycotting the vote in opposition.


Former President Michel Sleiman and the FPM had submitted appeals against the first extension law at the council, but the challenge was not heard after Shiite and Druze council members boycotted the sessions. The failure was protested by civil society activists, who through tomatoes and shouted slogans outside the council's office, accusing it of being controlled by political parties.


The council needs eight of its 10 members to attend any session for the quorum to be met, which is an exceptionally high percentage compared to other government institutions.


In a news conference Wednesday, the head of the council Issam Suleiman pledged that the body will meet the quorum to discuss the extension law.